Chefing It UP Pizza Cafe

Nestled in the heart of Groveland, Florida, Chefing It UP Pizza Cafe is a slice of authentic New York pizzaiolo tradition brought beautifully to the Sunshine State. Specializing in classic New York-style pizza, this cozy pizzeria offers a genuine culinary experience that transports you straight to the bustling streets of NYC with every crispy, foldable bite.

The charm of Chefing It UP lies not only in its mastery of dough but also in its imaginative menu where you can build your own pizza or surrender to one of their specialty pies. Their 18” XL and 16” large pizzas boast perfectly golden, crispy crusts that are light enough to fold yet sturdy enough to hold fresh, flavorful toppings – from the savory notes of pepperoni and sausage to the vibrant crunch of tri-color bell peppers and fresh garlic. The small 12” pie is ideal for a more intimate meal, but no less satisfying.

For those seeking something beyond the basics, the specialty pies are a delightful revelation. The “Queen” Margherita is a harmonious blend of fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, basil, and garlic that blossoms with fragrant, rustic simplicity. The Bianca “White” Pie surprises with creamy ricotta and mozzarella marrying with aromatic garlic and oil, a decadent twist that lingers on the palate. Veggie lovers will adore the Garden Pie, overflowing with colorful bell peppers, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, and black olives, while carnivores will find nirvana in the Carne pie—a hearty medley of pepperoni, sausage, ham, meatballs, and bacon that bursts with robust flavor.

The restaurant’s fresh salads also deserve a spotlight, especially the Antipasto Salad, where salami and provolone roll-ups come paired with roasted bell peppers, marinated mushrooms, and a balsamic herb vinaigrette that sings with a balance of sweetness and tang—each bite vibrant and refreshing. The Garden Salad, crisp and colorful with garden-fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, and parmesan, complements the pizza offerings perfectly.

What truly sets Chefing It UP Pizza Cafe apart is their dedication to authentic ingredient quality and a true New York approach. Customers repeatedly praise the perfectly cooked crust, the freshness of toppings, and the delicious cheese blends. One delighted guest remarked, “Pizza was incredible, crispy bottomed foldable New York style dough, excellent sauce, freshest ingredients...the cheese was delicious.” Another echoed, “This place has that NY style pizza I’ve been craving…Staff as well as owner were friendly and helpful. 10/10 recommend!”

The atmosphere, though laid-back and unpretentious, feels welcoming — the kind of place where you can enjoy a relaxed meal without fuss but with the certainty that every slice has been crafted with care and expertise. The owner’s NYC roots shine through in every detail, embodying a passion for traditional New York pizza culture that resonates deeply with both locals and visitors craving an honest, flavorful pie.

Whether you’re in the mood for a crispy, cheesy classic, a veggie-loaded delight, or a meat lover’s extravaganza, Chefing It UP Pizza Cafe promises to deliver a genuine and satisfying pizza experience that’s packed with flavor and heart. It’s a culinary gem in Groveland for anyone who values true pizza craftsmanship.

For authentic New York-style pizza accompanied by attentive service and an inviting vibe, look no further than Chefing It UP Pizza Cafe—where every bite tells a story of tradition, quality, and love for the craft.